Wycombe are unbeaten in their last four meetings with York in all competitions (W2 D2), with this the first since a 1-1 draw in League Two in April 2016.
York won their only previous meeting with Wycombe in the FA Cup proper, winning a third round tie 2-0 in January 1986.
Wycombe have been eliminated from the first round of the FA Cup in four of their last five appearances at this stage, though they did beat Bradford 2-1 in this round last season.
After eliminating Chester City at this stage of the competition last season, York are looking to reach the FA Cup second round in consecutive campaigns for the first time since 2009-10/2010-11.